Thursday, November 20, 2008

MMP question of the week - #2

Some have said that MMP gives disproportionate power to small parties.

Can one of them please explain how a handful of MPs (4? 5?) can out-vote the other 115-odd?

2 comments:

  1. By threatening to bring down their government if they don't get their way, obviously :)

    ReplyDelete
  2. Chris S: How's your math, Chris? :-)

    To bring down a government, the government have to lose a confidence vote.

    Losing a confidence vote means 61 out of 120 MPs don't support you......not 5.

    Again....How can 5 MPs outvote the other 115 odd?

    People who talk about "disproportionate power" are forgeting the role of the otehr 40,50 or 60 Mps who ALSO agree with the "minor" party....

    In short, they can't count (and don't want to).

    ReplyDelete

Thanks for deciding to share your thoughts here. In commenting on this blog, you can express any opinion you like, though any opinion expressed should make some attempt to be consistent with verifiable reality. Say what you like, confident that I won't delete any comments that are polite and respectful of me and others who may comment here. Civility aside, SPAM comments will be deleted if only because they are usually far too long and selling rubbish anyway. (Comments on posts older than 30 days are moderated. I'll approve them as soon as I can.)